Grumpy and recalcitrant patients get exactly what they wish for; worse medical care and mistakes by the medical practitioner.

Does this bring to mind a particular Ozpolitic denizen? Hmmm.

http://www.upi.com/Health_News/2016/03/15/Difficult-patients-may-tend-to-get-worse-care-studies-find/7791458064325/


Quote:

TUESDAY, March 15, 2016 -- What happens to medical care when the patient is a jerk? Dutch researchers asked the question in two new studies, and the answer should make grumps think the better of their bad behavior: "Disruptive" patients may get worse care from physicians. The findings aren't definitive because the researchers tested how physicians responded in fictional vignettes, instead of real-life encounters. Still, the results suggest that patients who make a scene distract physicians from doing their jobs. "Patients who behave disruptively by displaying disrespect or aggressiveness may induce their doctors to make diagnostic mistakes," said Dr. Silvia Mamede, who worked on both studies. She is an associate professor with the Institute of Medical Education Research Rotterdam at Erasmus Medical Center in the Netherlands. An estimated 15 percent of patients treated in doctors' offices are aggressive, disrespectful, overly demanding or distrustful, Mamede said. "As might be expected, these behaviors provoke emotional reactions in doctors," she said. But do these patients actually get worse care? Physicians have long talked about this question, but researchers haven't investigated that issue, according to Mamede. The study authors could have monitored actual doctors' visits to find an answer, but Mamede said that approach would have been "virtually impossible" because each case is so different. Instead, the researchers created vignettes about "neutral" patients and disruptive patients who do things such as make frequent demands, ignore the doctor's advice and act helpless. Then they asked physicians to diagnose the patients. This approach is "feasible, ethical and reasonable," said Dr. Donald Redelmeier, senior core scientist with the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences in Toronto. Redelmeier co-wrote a commentary accompanying the study. In one study of 63 family medicine physicians from Rotterdam, "doctors made 42 percent more mistakes in disruptive than in non-disruptive patients when the cases were complex, and 6 percent more mistakes when the cases were simple," Mamede said. (The physicians did a better job when they had more time to think about their diagnoses; experts determined the correct diagnoses.) The other study, which included 74 internal medicine residents, produced similar findings: In cases considered to be moderately complex, "doctors made 20 percent more mistakes in difficult compared to neutral patients," she added. The studies don't provide information about how often the physicians got a diagnosis completely correct or missed it entirely. Instead, the researchers scored the diagnoses based on whether they were correct, partially correct or wrong. What's going on? Mamede said disruptive patients distract physicians by "capturing" their attention, preventing them from focusing more on actual medical conditions. It's not clear, she said, if poorer care will make disruptive patients even more frustrating to deal with over time, creating a vicious cycle of increasing disruption and more inaccurate diagnoses. But Redelmeier said such a "negative feedback loop" is possible. What can be done? "Physicians should be trained to deal with these disruptive behaviors explicitly and effectively," Mamede said. "An aggressive patient can be calmed. A patient who displays lack of trust in his doctor can be referred to another doctor," she suggested. As for patients, Redelmeier referred to the points he and a co-author make in the commentary. Patients, they explained, can try to channel their emotion into polite comments; for example, "Thank you for seeing me. I am frightened by what I am experiencing and that is why I am here looking for something that might help." Still, the editorialists added, "real people . . . cannot always control their temper when suffering or in pain." More research is needed to figure out the best approaches, Redelmeier suggested.

Really?  So a dear old lady suffering from gout and various ailments who is grumpy is also forced to endure a medical practicioner with no empathy, and even receive lesser treatment because she is in pain?

Lovely - just lovely..... but then - when you're a God, there is no need to tolerate the grumps and moans of the mere mortals...

No wonder receptionists at hospitals imagine themselves overseers of all they see.... and the final adjudicator of whatever they may happen to feel at any given time...

Insolence of officer and clear proof that often the wrong people are getting into medical professions.  Oh, well...

Grappler Deep State Feller wrote on Mar 16^th, 2016 at 12:49pm:

Really?  So a dear old lady suffering from gout and various ailments who is grumpy is also forced to endure a medical practicioner with no empathy, and even receive lesser treatment because she is in pain? Lovely - just lovely..... but then - when you're a God, there is no need to tolerate the grumps and moans of the mere mortals... No wonder receptionists at hospitals imagine themselves overseers of all they see.... and the final adjudicator of whatever they may happen to feel at any given time... Insolence of officer and clear proof that often the wrong people are getting into medical professions.  Oh, well...

[smiley=thumbup.gif]

Grappler Deep State Feller wrote on Mar 16^th, 2016 at 12:49pm:

Really?  So a dear old lady suffering from gout and various ailments who is grumpy is also forced to endure a medical practicioner with no empathy, and even receive lesser treatment because she is in pain? Lovely - just lovely..... but then - when you're a God, there is no need to tolerate the grumps and moans of the mere mortals... No wonder receptionists at hospitals imagine themselves overseers of all they see.... and the final adjudicator of whatever they may happen to feel at any given time... Insolence of officer and clear proof that often the wrong people are getting into medical professions.  Oh, well...

I cant think of anything worse...

than being in a job where you are meant to make people feel better and all you get in return is abuse..

ask yourself grap... what you would be like if the person you are giving the best treatment in the world and all they do is kick and scream at you or call you names...

I patient can choose a doctor but a doctor doesnt choose his patients....

I say its unacceptable for people to abuse anyone

but our health workers should always be respected......of course some dont have a bedside manner... is that an excuse to abuse????????? >:( >:( >:(