Australian Politics Forum | |
http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl
General Discussion >> Federal Politics >> Stan Grant http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1460774390 Message started by bogarde73 on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:39pm |
Title: Stan Grant Post by bogarde73 on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:39pm
Great, an embittered grub, full of hatred for the white men in his ancestry, is to be some symbol of reconciliation.
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Leftwinger on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:44pm
Here is the story so you don't have to guess what it is Bogarde is to lazy to post up :D
Popular broadcaster Stan Grant will help lead the nation towards the constitutional recognition of Indigenous people. Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and Opposition Leader Bill Shorten have appointed Mr Grant, a Wiradjuri man and award-winning reporter, to the Referendum Council on constitutional recognition. Mr Grant will replace Indigenous leader Patrick Dodson, who has resigned to enter the Senate for Labor. Stan Grant will advise Malcolm Turnbull and Bill Shorten on a referendum to recognise Indigenous people in the constitution Stan Grant will advise Malcolm Turnbull and Bill Shorten on a referendum to recognise Indigenous people in the constitution Photo: Kathy Luu Mr Turnbull and Mr Shorten will announce the appointment in a rare joint press release, Fairfax Media can reveal. Advertisement "Mr Grant's extensive experience and commitment to constitutional recognition and Indigenous affairs will be invaluable in the role as a member of the Referendum Council," the leaders will say. The council was established last year to lead national consultations and advise the government on how best to proceed with the planned referendum to maximise its chances for success. Malcolm Turnbull was moved to tears during a recent interview with Stan Grant. Malcolm Turnbull was moved to tears during a recent interview with Stan Grant. Photo: The Point, NITV Other members of the council include Indigenous leaders Mick Gooda, Noel Pearson and Galarrwuy Yunupingu. It also includes former politicians such as Amanda Vanstone, Kristina Keneally and Natasha Stott Despoja. The appointment comes two months after Mr Grant revealed he was considering a career in politics. It's understood he has had discussions with both the Liberal and Labor parties but is yet to decide whether to run for preselection for either side. He has said he is not "ideologically bound to the left". He was reportedly approached to run for Liberal preselection in the marginal Labor seat of Parramatta. He publicly ruled out running for the Nationals after being approached by Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce. Mr Grant started considering a run for Parliament after the overwhelming response to a speech on racism he gave last year. In the speech delivered at the IQ2 Racism Debate in October, Grant declared that racism is "killing the Australian dream". The speech found its way online and quickly went viral on social media, attracting comparisons to Martin Luther King. "The Australian dream - we sing of it and we recite it in verse: 'Australians all let us rejoice for we are young and free'," he said in the speech. "But my people die young in this country - we die 10 years younger than average Australians - and we are far from free." Mr Grant has worked as a political reporter, news anchor and foreign correspondent over his illustrious 30-year career. The Walkley Award-winner currently works for Sky News, NITV and the Guardian Australia. Read more:http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/stan-grant-to-advise-malcolm-turnbull-on-indigenous-recognition-20160416-go7vrf.html#ixzz45xBb55fq Follow us: @smh on Twitter | sydneymorningherald on Facebook |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Karnal on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:45pm
Arbeit macht frei, no?
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Mr Hammer on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:48pm
"But my people die young in this country - we die 10 years younger than average Australians - and we are far from free."
his people? he a mongrel blood whiteman. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Fireball on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:50pm Mr Hammer wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:48pm:
It's the EvoStik they use.........and the metho..... |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Mr Hammer on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:52pm Fuzzball wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:50pm:
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Leftwinger on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:54pm I care about the blacks :'( :'( :'( |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Leftwinger on Apr 16th, 2016 at 1:00pm
Boges would like to introduce his new minister for indigenous affairs , drum roll
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Mr Hammer on Apr 16th, 2016 at 1:02pm Its time wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 1:00pm:
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by cods on Apr 16th, 2016 at 1:57pm
oh dear........well this aint going to be pretty thats for sure..
but the bleedinghearts will be overjoyed....do you think all those who signed the sorry paper or walked the bridge are still high fiving each other.???... did it stop the whingeing?????? ::) ::) just askin. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by LEUT Bigvicfella (RTD) on Apr 16th, 2016 at 2:14pm
"It's understood he has had discussions with both the Liberal and Labor parties but is yet to decide whether to run for preselection for either side. He has said he is not "ideologically bound to the left".
Good Stan, there is soon to be a vacancy in Bronnie's old electorate - run for that. You and Mal can move each other to tears, and helicopter rides are part of the package. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Honest Joe on Apr 16th, 2016 at 4:42pm bogarde73 wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:39pm:
Why do you say that? Because he cares for the plight of his people? |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by BatteriesNotIncluded on Apr 16th, 2016 at 4:57pm Fuzzball wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:50pm:
What's 'EvoStik'? |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by BatteriesNotIncluded on Apr 16th, 2016 at 4:59pm cods wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 1:57pm:
Do women ever stop whingeing? just askin. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by The Mechanic on Apr 16th, 2016 at 6:00pm
I remember when stan grant used to be white..
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Mr Hammer on Apr 16th, 2016 at 6:03pm President Elect, The Mechanic wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 6:00pm:
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Honest Joe on Apr 16th, 2016 at 8:52pm President Elect, The Mechanic wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 6:00pm:
Was that when you were blissfully ignorant to his heritage. Pretty sure his first wife was aboriginal and a news presenter for NITV. Don't quote me but fairly certain. Anyway some comments on here make me realise why we need to continue to support these people. It seems a conservative mindset is shallow on everything. True. :D |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Webtoad on Apr 16th, 2016 at 8:59pm
If we can have a referendum on this then we can also have a referendum on the introduction of homosexual marriage.
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Lord Herbert on Apr 16th, 2016 at 9:02pm
Quote:
Mr Grant started considering a run for Parliament after the overwhelming response to a speech on racism he gave last year. In the speech delivered at the IQ2 Racism Debate in October, Grant declared that racism is "killing the Australian dream". The speech found its way online and quickly went viral on social media, attracting comparisons to Martin Luther King. He should get out more. Get on a Sydney train - check out the colour of the passengers ... then get off the train anywhere in the Sydney area and count the number of Darkies and Orientals compared to the whites. Grant is blowing it out his black arse. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Lord Herbert on Apr 16th, 2016 at 9:04pm Webtoad wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 8:59pm:
;D ;D ;D There's nothing stopping you now from putting your ring on his finger ... |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by boxy on Apr 16th, 2016 at 9:08pm
Oh the humanity! Appointing someone who represents one of the major stakeholders in the referendum topic to a committee designed to prepare it ::)
Meh, committees are notoriously bad at getting referendums up. It's like they deliberately design them to fail. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by aquascoot on Apr 17th, 2016 at 6:50am
there is a path forward for aborigines and it is the same path as for every human on the planet.
the path of higher consciousness. eat good food take physical exercise have a mission in life bigger then yourself take the "positivity challenge"...everything negative that happens...quickly reframe it as a positive. read good books get good positive mentors if a friend or relative is negative ....cut them. mediate for 20 minutes a day approach everything with a spirit of contribution. This will be a very hard road for the aboriginal. poor nutrition makes it hard to concentrate alcohol makes it hard to focus. the philosophy of the fellow aboriginal tends to be negative the philosophy of the white establishment tends to be that of pitying the aboriginal rather then encouraging and challenging the aboriginal. there is little emotional mastery, there is a lot of anger and fearfulness....you suffer doubly thru this....firstly who wants to feel angry and fearful, secondly, you cant achieve much when your emotions are negative and neurotic. literacy is low , so reading great books is hard. the few aboriginals who have succeeded do not seem good mentors. stan grant and adam goodes for example are successful. why are they not spreading a positive message of encouragement and challenge. they continue the cry baby narrative and , in what way could this possibly be inspirational to someone who is already in a very very difficult position. the whole psychology and philosophy from those charged with helping aboriginals is toxic, negative and unhelpful. young aboriginals would do well to be raised by caring white cattlemen in the Northern Terrotory where they will be challenged, stimulated, taught, inspired and build self esteem. they will certainly continue to suffer under the guidance of low consciousness white and black cry babies |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by The Mechanic on Apr 17th, 2016 at 7:26am aquascoot wrote on Apr 17th, 2016 at 6:50am:
excellent thread.. and it would be great for them to be taken out of their alcohol fuelled cesspits and into care of work, learning and self pride.. but we'd then get the leftist scum "crying" about a "stolen" generation.. ::) |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Honest Joe on Apr 17th, 2016 at 7:48am aquascoot wrote on Apr 17th, 2016 at 6:50am:
Ah yes, all those things they had prior to 1788. Gee I wonder what happened? Citizenship rights came about in 1967. So for close to 200 years up until 40 odd years ago they had little rights. Segregation was still alive and well into the 70's. They were restricted from using their language, cultural practices and placed on missions and reserves without any option to leave for most of that 200 years. They were given 2nd grade education if any at all etc etc, and you still wonder why there are challenges with these people. The good news is since 1967 (40 odd years) I'd heard that there have been about 30 000 university graduates, possibly more. There is not much more we can expect in such a short period time and attempts to break cycles that have been deeply ingrained due to our government's restrictions on these people. By the way, it wasn't you or I that caused this mess and no we shouldn't feel responsible, but we can make a positive constributions by being informed. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by aquascoot on Apr 17th, 2016 at 8:05am Honest Joe wrote on Apr 17th, 2016 at 7:48am:
dear Honest Joe. i had the misfortune to be in central Qld when the labor premier, the honourable Wayne Goss , opened the community alcohol distribution centre in Wurrabinda...previously dry (a large community west of rcokhampton). You can go there and see the commemorative bronze plaque on the wall. as you walk about the community you will see a scene of third world squalor . The honorable Joh Bjelke Petersen allowed the baptist mission to run the community at Hopevale near cairns.(a very positive joyful place with lots of signing and good emotions at that time) It was a dry community until the labor government also established grog outlets in a spirit of "equality".(now its a place that feels evil) The local high school to hopevale (Yarabah) has nearly 1500 aboriginal students. Last year, the dux of this high school , was unable to pass the enrolment test to get a job at cairns Mcdonalds. 30,000 university students????.... i will gaurantee you these are white folk with 1/8 or 1/16 aboriginal heritage who identified as aboriginal to access the "aboriginal welfare"gravy that should be given to the communities. We must face the fact that 100 billion dollars of leftard canberra spending and lots of hand wringing and futile symbolic BS (thanking the traditional owners seems to be in vogue at even whitey school assemblies) has contributed not ONE thing to the advancement of aboriginals. In fact, the communities are a disgraceful hot bed of fetal alcohol syndrome, sexual violence, sexually transmitted disease, obesity and woeful nutrition and a totally negative mindset. The aborigine is a natural cattleman and worker of the land. We have enormous opportunities to sell beef to a burgeoning asian middle class. Stick your university and leftard "out of touch " BS up your jumper . Let the people who really know the aborigine help the aborigine (rural folk). Lefty city intellectuals from the green and labor party should stick to what they know best....dinner parties, watching the mardi gras on SBS and fretting about palestinians ;) |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Armchair_Politician on Apr 17th, 2016 at 8:49am Its time wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 12:44pm:
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people have all the same rights as other people in Australia. Segregation ended decades ago. Per person, ATSI people get considerably more government funding than any other group. So if we're going to specifically recognise ATSI people in the Constitution, then we should do the same for Anglo, Asian, Lebanese, Italian, Greek, Chinese and all other groups of Australian citizens. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Honest Joe on Apr 17th, 2016 at 10:58am
dear Honest Joe.
i had the misfortune to be in central Qld when the labor premier, the honourable Wayne Goss , opened the community alcohol distribution centre in Wurrabinda...previously dry (a large community west of rcokhampton). You can go there and see the commemorative bronze plaque on the wall. as you walk about the community you will see a scene of third world squalor . The honorable Joh Bjelke Petersen allowed the baptist mission to run the community at Hopevale near cairns.(a very positive joyful place with lots of signing and good emotions at that time) It was a dry community until the labor government also established grog outlets in a spirit of "equality".(now its a place that feels evil) The local high school to hopevale (Yarabah) has nearly 1500 aboriginal students. Last year, the dux of this high school , was unable to pass the enrolment test to get a job at cairns Mcdonalds. 30,000 university students????.... i will gaurantee you these are white folk with 1/8 or 1/16 aboriginal heritage who identified as aboriginal to access the "aboriginal welfare"gravy that should be given to the communities. We must face the fact that 100 billion dollars of leftard canberra spending and lots of hand wringing and futile symbolic BS (thanking the traditional owners seems to be in vogue at even whitey school assemblies) has contributed not ONE thing to the advancement of aboriginals. In fact, the communities are a disgraceful hot bed of fetal alcohol syndrome, sexual violence, sexually transmitted disease, obesity and woeful nutrition and a totally negative mindset. The aborigine is a natural cattleman and worker of the land. We have enormous opportunities to sell beef to a burgeoning asian middle class. Stick your university and leftard "out of touch " BS up your jumper . Let the people who really know the aborigine help the aborigine (rural folk). Lefty city intellectuals from the green and labor party should stick to what they know best....dinner parties, watching the mardi gras on SBS and fretting about palestinians ;)[/quote] I think most people who are negative about this issue care and people who aren't also care. The difference is seeing the issues so differently. The damage was done due to draconian policies that restricted these people from functioning under their traditional practices and denial of functioning in western society, but more importantly the ability to transition freely. You are talking about generations upon generations of denial and rejection of a whole collective group of people. There is going to be pain coming out of paternalistic care. The problem is like many other political issues, is that aboriginal affairs is a political toy. As for those people who you distinguish as having varying levels of aboriginal blood is that they are from aboriginal heritage and ancestory goes back 80k years despite the shallow idea of grading people based on blood. We identify ourselves by nationalism and generally not strong race connections. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by aquascoot on Apr 17th, 2016 at 1:00pm
Joe,
they just arent that smart. They , therefore, need good leadership. What the lefties would call my "paternalistic' attitude, i would call helping out people who are struggling. loons in canberra who think that the way to measure success is to see how many aboriginals go to uni are totally missing the point and being mischievious. Of course, if you get a lot of white people with a small percentage of aboriginal blood and let them call themselves aboriginal, then they might go to uni and get a degree. then you can jump up in parliament and brag about how under your policies , more and more aboriginals are succeeding . it is a load of BS. it does nothing for the aboriginals , the "real" aboriginals , in the bush. they aint going to uni my friend. can they still lead a rich happy and successful life? damm straight they can, working in the bush , getting in touch with animals and nature and the climate and going walkabout . It is "cruel and unusual punishment" to put an aborigine in redfern. I cant stand inner city vibe and i'm white. the lefties need to leave aboriginal welfare to the alpha whites in the bush who approach the issue with a spirit of contribution and want to "help" them, not "use" them to boost their own egoic state |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by bogarde73 on Apr 17th, 2016 at 1:10pm
I'll say more about the bastard. He got the family name, that's enough.
If it was good enough for Tom Jefferson it's good enough for the squatters. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Honest Joe on Apr 17th, 2016 at 2:44pm
:-/
aquascoot wrote on Apr 17th, 2016 at 1:00pm:
That's a huge call to say they aren't real smart. Take a look back at the traditional setting. Lived in Australia 80k years or longer. It was a socialistic society of living with nature. Blood lines were pure, which meant no deformities etc. The common cold was non existent. So strict guidelines for marriage were established. There were never battles for territory, everyone had a place in maintaining and nurturing their place of connection. Trees were never cut down or destroyed and animals were never killed off. There was a season for everything, which were strictly obeyed by lore. No one had personal ownership, everything was shared. Population was controlled in relation to natural food and water supplies. There is evidence and anecdote that men cut themselves to ensure wives would not become pregnant. They survived for that long in relative harmony and keeping their place in pristine condition and you say they aren't smart. What you are measuring against are your own values in terms of intelligence. You probably think because we built mud huts and made Ricketty old boats 200 years ago that we were somehow smarter. Aborigines aren't motivated by what motivates us. Things have changed as a consequence of messing with the fabric of their society, but suggesting they're not smart is a bold egotistical statement. I have a university degree but certainly would not classify myself smarter than billy bob down the road who cleans for a living. I may have a big boat and a flash house but just because he lives in a little flat doesn't not mean I'm smarter. It mostly means I have different values. Step off your high horse I say. You don't have to put others down to feel good about yourself. This is partly why our world is gone mad. On identity.....I have a mixture of European blood lines and could have some form of black lineage (negoid anyway) somewhere and you may have too. Who bloody knows. I identify as an Australian. My family migrated from the good old mother land a few generations back. Identity is not just the colour of your skin, it encapsulates everything about you including values, practices and general sense of connection. To say someone is not an aborigine based on the colour of skin is one of the most superficial lines I hear from people who need something or someone to measure against to make them feel good about themselves. Hey, I was as ignorant as anyone until I figured something didn't make sense regarding these people and I certainly didn't want to draw conclusions from the shallow pool of knowledge that I see here. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by aquascoot on Apr 17th, 2016 at 3:08pm
you are quite right in what you say but therein lies the conflict.
the city folk want to define "smart' as going to uni or other measures of "closing the gap" based on urban intellectual concepts. and , no, they arent smart in this way. sure they are smart in other ways, if you sent a couple of aboriginal lads out in the tanami desert to check on some bores and you sent a couple of children of canberra public servants out on the same mission, i know who i would be putting money on to return safely. it still boils down, in my experience, to the fact that a lot of country folk integrate aboriginals into their communities and really are rooting for them to succeed and a lot of city folk , intellectually masturbate about aboriginals and their entire experience of aboriginals is based on celebrities like Grant or Goodes. The remote and rural aboriginal has bonds to the land the same as the farmer, they get on great. the fly in , fly out miner....would never speak to one i imagine....he would live in his little compound in his air conditioned donger. the city person trying to put forward ideas on aboriginals....oh please, give me a break. They just embarrass themselves due to their ignorance |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Armchair_Politician on Apr 17th, 2016 at 3:44pm President Elect, The Mechanic wrote on Apr 16th, 2016 at 6:00pm:
He seems to have over-done his time in the tanning bed, doesn't he. Then: Now: |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Mr Hammer on Apr 17th, 2016 at 3:49pm Armchair_Politician wrote on Apr 17th, 2016 at 3:44pm:
|
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Honest Joe on Apr 17th, 2016 at 4:38pm aquascoot wrote on Apr 17th, 2016 at 3:08pm:
The Goodes, the grants, the inglis's, the dodson's all play their part. It's to say that you can make something of yourself. Look on the whole people do want the best for aborigines. Hey, you and I are aware that underlying sentiment isn't positive for various reasons. David Uniopon on the $50 note was an inventer. A traditional man. He invented the sheep sheers and prototype of the helicopter blade. I also read an archival document a few years back and keen to locate again. Anyway, it was an experiment where they basically provided a traditional aboriginal girl exactly the same educational opportunities as all students over a period of time. I think in NSW and from memory back in late 20th century. The young traditional girl topped the state. They are smart. I believe aborigines should harness the evolutionary effect just the same as us. We didn't create our society individually but we learnt to live with it and evolve with the changes. This means that they change their whole value system. While there are many breaking the cycle there are many still stuck in communities that are absolute cesspits. One elder suggested that many of these people feared leaving their communities, firstly a fear of not being accepted in the broader community due to lack of confidence and backlash as a consequence of being seen as a "big noter" who is turning their back on their family. It's a bloody complex situation that has no easy answers or answers that will provide a quick fix. Good discussing this with you though. All the best. |
Title: Re: Stan Grant Post by Lord Herbert on Apr 17th, 2016 at 6:25pm Armchair_Politician wrote on Apr 17th, 2016 at 3:44pm:
His physiognomy bears not the slightest resemblance to aboriginal features. Zero. |
Australian Politics Forum » Powered by YaBB 2.5.2! YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2024. All Rights Reserved. |