Quote: Straight after 9/11 he flew to afghanistan to report for duty. Who would do that ??
He was already in Pakistan, the neighbouring country.
Quote: he was given his own muslim name. mohammad dawood.
So were Cat Stevens and Cassius Clay. Are they terrorists too? Its part of becoming a muslim.
Quote: he was given a weapon, about 50 rounds of ammo and a few hand granades.
I would hope so, he was a soldier. Or are muslims supposed to fight with wooden swords?
Quote: He was guarding a tank for a time, got bored and went off to 'find some more action". In his own words. He did find action, and ran.
The Taliban wouldn't let him fight on the front line. Hicks was a flake who could not follow orders. Would you put him on the front line?
SC, you are missing the whole point of Hicks being detained at GITMO. The Bush government said all those housed there were terrorists, and not only that, they were the worst of the worst.
Hicks is immature and uneducated. He was looking for acceptance, and wound up getting suckered into a war in Afghanistan.
He admitted to aiding the enemy, and for that he was given a 7 year sentence, reduced to 9 months on the proviso that he aided the prosecution in future cases.
There is no doubt that what he did was wrong. The issue here is the length of his detention, and the denial of justice. The fact is, he was given a 9 month sentence, which indicates that he is of NO THREAT TO ANYONE. He will be a free man in 2008. If there was any suggestion that he was a terrorist, do you really think he would be allowed back on the streets?