freediver wrote on Jun 12
th, 2008 at 8:11pm:
'God's existence is unknowable' is different from 'I don't know if God exists'.
That's a bit 'academic' isn't it? Are there any people who believe that God's existence is unknowable, yet know that god exists? Are there any people who don't know whether God exists, but consider it knowable?
Yes - I don't
know absolutely whether God exists or not, but consider that it could be knowable to others. I'm an Agnostic.
I base my
belief on whether there is evidence or not. There is no evidence (for me). Therefore I don't believe in God - I'm an atheist.
Quote:The important thing is what you believe - not the label.
Not entirely. Effecive communication requires understanding, which cannot happen if the meaning of words is never clarified. The meaning of words depend on their context. THat's why you have to explain what you mean by them - contextualise them.
That's why we have language. Some words are not exact and are ambiguous, but we acquire the sense of what is being said based on the context.
Quote:Ultimately I don't even use the term 'atheist' to describe myself because my religious position is not a central tenet of earth shattering significance to me, and because there is so much confusion about the terminology anyway.
So you see where the confusion leads - difficulty in communication. You have to explain yourself when a single word should suffice.
There is such a clean and simple distinction that fits the 'general understanding' perfectly - athiests, believe/know/have decided, whereas agnostics haven't. There is no need to surrender to the confusion. I suspect the problem is that people tend to use atheist as a catch all term if they are unfamiliar with the term agnostic. But that is no reason to let two different words lose their distinction.
Agnostics haven't believed/known/ decided ? I'm not sure that I follow you. Your definition sounds anything but clean and simple.
The fact is that other people, some much smarter than you or me have argued the point of definition of atheist and Agnostic ad nauseum. Now the various flavours of Atheist may not be important to you from the standpoint of a Christian, or a theist. Your world view in itself tends to simplify that which is quite subtle. In the same way, I probably don't quite get it right when I'm talking about Christians, Muslims etc.