mozzaok wrote on Jan 15
th, 2009 at 7:03pm:
I realise you are just joking, and it is a bit of fun to have a go at grendel, but there is a serious issue being discussed here, whether you agree or not.
All of us who do not agree with everything in Islam being praiseworthy, are likely to have had posts deleted, sometimes we expected it, but more often did not.
When I chose to insult Lestat, I fully expected the posts to be deleted, and that is not what I am taking issue with.
When I criticise an aspect of Islam, that I find offensive, or questionable, and do not use any personal insults, or bad language, which you all know I very rarely do anyway, to then have that post just disappear, because it is not respectful to Islam, then that is a problem.
If it were not an aspect I did not respect, I would not be raising it in the first place, so to reserve the right, used arbitrarily, to protect Islams good name, makes a joke of being able to frankly discuss our opinions on the forum at all.
Now I will add that it has not been a huge issue for me, and I generally word my posts more moderately than some, but I think the principle of freedom of speech is important, and I also think Abu has been more open to allowing criticism lately, than he was earlier on, but still, if we have anything we think may be considered controversial to say about Islam, we use another board, because we know that it will disappear from Islam, or Extremism Exposed.
That is not an ideal situation.
Is Abu seriously doing that?
If so, he should add these sentences to his
riot act:
"Please enjoy your stay. Oh, and by the way, there will be no debate on the Islam board. Only nice things should be said about Islam, because I'm trying to give it a positive image. What do you think this is? A political forum or something?"
Seriously though, if anyone has a problem with Abu's moderation,
just post something on the extremism board, because we know how unbiased Gaybriel is with Islam just post on either 'thinking globally' or 'general.'