Forum

 
  Back to OzPolitic.com   Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
  Forum Home Album HelpSearch Recent Rules LoginRegister  
 

Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
Why sharia is untenable (Read 815 times)
Soren
Gold Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 25654
Gender: male
Why sharia is untenable
Mar 6th, 2009 at 10:01pm
 
Sharia law, god-focused as it is, attempts to deals with every aspect of muslim life, public and private, as life was in the 7th century or as life today can be conjured out of the cultural memory of that 7th century life. It invokes god and covers banking, marriage, cleanliness, religious practice, property and personal injury disputes and all the rest of life as it existed a millenium and a half ago..

What sharia is incapable of, and what renders it untenable beyond taliban-like atavistic attempts (doomed to bloody failure), is that it has nothing to say, and never will have,  on the mundane. It is unable to deal with the mundane as mundane. It is utterly incapable to separate the divine from the mundane - god and caesar, holy and profane, mosque and state. Sharia iss blind to the mundane, the worldly. For sharia, there is no possible separation.

As a consequence, there is no guidance on how to run a municipality, a school council, a chook raffle, a club or university - except to run them as if. As if the minutea of rubbish collection, road maintenance, sport education or the allocation of research funds were divine matters, as if today's mundane concerns were the same as the worldly concerns of the 7th century.

Sharia codifies life as it was then - whole and small scale in villages and small town - and life as it is now must conform to that memory. But of course it won't and so life, the worldly, the mundane will make its own way. And there is the rub. Life will make its own way and sharia cannot contain it because sharia is stuck in the mundane of the 'back then'. And sharia is not a self-repairing system, so it will be forever stuck, never to catch up. The very definition of an anachronism.

I think this is at least one of the reasons why all jurisdictions purporting to be 'islamic' or sharia based at least, cannot shake off corruption, nepotism, tyranny and plain bastardliness. Sharia or Islamic rules are unfit for the flux of the mundane, the lowly, the daily grind which changes beyond recognition over time.  
In my view, this is precisekly wwhy it iss embraaced only by tribal societies( and probably tribal-minded individuals0 despitee its preteensions to universality. It iss unable to deal with thee varieety and flux that universality actually means. Islam is conformist first and last, that is its only universality.

Life today, the white noise of mundane change and flux, rubs up against Islamic jurisdictions and they must either ignore it or succumb to it.  The former leads to psychosis (denial of reality), the latter to corruption as sharia attempts to mould the mundane to the ideals and strictures of a 1400 year old world - or vica versa.

The big stuff is unchanging but the little stuff is fluid, flowing and never the same. Sharia can only deal with the flux as if it didn't exist, as if flux was static. Sharia deals in contradictions and is therefore inpractical and consequently untenable. Sharia has the grip of a dying man on reality, cramped and creepy. It can capture the imagination only of the deaf.

Discuss.

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Yadda
Gold Member
*****
Online



Posts: 21682
A cat with a view
Re: Why sharia is untenable
Reply #1 - Mar 7th, 2009 at 6:24pm
 
Soren wrote on Mar 6th, 2009 at 10:01pm:
....I think this is at least one of the reasons why all jurisdictions purporting to be 'islamic' or sharia based at least, cannot shake off corruption, nepotism, tyranny and plain bastardliness.




That is a blindingly obvious statement of TRUTH.

To a rational person.





Sharia.....

Many aspects of Sharia plainly have consequences for its subjects [victims!] which are absurd and unjust.

Yet no breathing muslim will dare to criticise this, anachronism, Sharia.

Q.
Why?

Q.
Is it because rational muslims cannot see the absurdities and injustices, which Sharia embraces?

No.

The reason there is no criticism of Sharia, is because apart from regulating all aspects of a believers life, Sharia also codifies the punishments, for any criticism of its own [Sharia's] authority.

Sharia codifies the terrorising of its critics.

And there are many, many examples where brave rational people ['muslims'] are being murdered, for a rational thought,
....expressed.


Google,
critic of suicide bombing murdered
http://www.google.com.au/search?hl=en&q=critic+of+suicide+bombing+murdered&btnG=...

Google,
criticism Sharia outrage
http://www.google.com.au/search?hl=en&q=criticism+Sharia+outrage&btnG=Search&met...


October 1, 2007
Imam shot dead the day after he spoke out against Islamic jihadists
.....Wonder why more peaceful Muslims don't speak out against the jihad?

http://www.jihadwatch.org/archives/018328.php


May 14, 2008
Afghan teacher shot dead after speech condemning suicide bombings
Why Islamic reform is about as likely as an attack by men from Mars, part 65320: "Afghan teacher killed after speech condemning suicide bombings," from The Associated Press, May 14 (thanks to Jeffrey Imm):
.....KABUL, Afghanistan: A teacher was shot to death in northern Afghanistan after he gave a speech condemning suicide bombings, officials said Wednesday.
.....Hadi spoke at a gathering of about 700 people, including the Kunduz governor, and was on his way home when he was killed,

http://www.jihadwatch.org/archives/021017.phpi
Sharia is an abuse [a perversion?] of justice and TRUTH.

But yet, devout muslims flock to its control of their lives.

Q.
Why?

A.
Is it because some ppl are actually perversely attracted to the terror, encapsulated within the Sharia 'package'?

Some individuals, lust for [political] worldly power, and lust for patriarchal power within their families.

Do devout muslims imagine, that Sharia will deliver the power and control which they seek, which they lust after?








Perhaps here, we should look at another thread?.....

"Islam as psychosis"

http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1235817863i
Back to top
 

"....And he said unto him, If they hear not Moses and the prophets, neither will they be persuaded, though one rose from the dead."
Luke 16:31
 
IP Logged
 
Soren
Gold Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 25654
Gender: male
Re: Why sharia is untenable
Reply #2 - Mar 7th, 2009 at 7:18pm
 
The sharia punishment for merely thinking for oneself is well made. Islam, as all parodies, wants to go one better - it wants to be unthinking becasue it takes thinking to be rebellious against god. A step too far, as with all farces.


Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print