Quote:Erdogan is quite a staunch secularist
Can you explain why he said this?
Quote:"One Cannot Be a Muslim, and Secular"
Quote:Besides haven't you always argued democracy merely means electing your leader? If this is the case, then democracy should have nothing to do with secularism.
My concern is for Turkey's democracy. If I thought they were to get rid of secularism but maintain democracy, I would not have a problem. But I think that is unlikely.
Also, secularism is important to protect freedom of religion. Again, not directly linked to democracy, but also important.
Ultimately, I think secularism is necessary for both democracy and freedom. By secularism I mean avoiding institutional connections between government and religion. This still allows religion to play a strong role via democratic processes.
Quote:So you must now agree then that it's more than just merely electing a leader.
You have to have regular elections. Electing a leader once and then turing into a doctatorship is not democratic.
Quote:Interesting parallel, especially since Hitler was a secularist.
I suspect you are missing the point. People can have all sorts of motives (usually power lust) for overturing a democracy. Democracy must be protected, whatever the ideology of the wannabe dictator.
Quote:In other words you feel the military should always hold the ultimate power in a country, and civilian government is only to be tolerated if it is to fall in line with the ideals of those who are heads in the military?
No. For democracy to function there must be a balance of power. Putting too much power in the hands of one individual or group inevitably leads to problems. Obviously this balance is a bit problematic in a Muslim country where so many oppose democracy.
Quote:Isn't that called military dictatorship?
As far as I know, Turkey's military has always promptly returned power to the people via democracy.