freediver wrote on Apr 10^th, 2014 at 8:41pm:


Talk about dumb!

I checked the website, it has two Quran quotes -one reference to the punishments of people who rob using weapons. There is another reference to something that angels did - not Prophet Muhammed.

Then I looked at the hadeeths; 17 of them describe the same single incident of murderous robbers being punished. Another hadeeth describes something that the Prophet was considering, but did not actually do. Another hadeeth describes something that somebody else did, which the Prophet had said not to do. Yet another hadeeth simply saying that Hell will be hot.


The rest are of the stories are unverifiable because they are not Quran verses or hadeeth.

Quote:


So only the official Islamic version of history counts? Is this like Gandalf's dodgy website that insisted the account of Muhammed torturing a Jew to get his Jew gold cannot be trusted because it must have been recorded by Jews, even though the "alternative" story it offered is very similar?

Quote:


Great. Now there are two vague references to torture with no details at all. Obviously Muslims didn't make up those stories and the endless victimhood posturing and Jew/Pagan slaughtering is entirely justified.