Karnal wrote on Aug 10^th, 2015 at 10:09am:


FD, what's the best way to get someone to answer a question? You're good at this.

Should I just keep repeating it, or should I ask it in a separate thread?

freediver wrote on Aug 11^th, 2015 at 12:16pm:


Terrible example, which we've been through before, and which you bizarrely somehow interpreted my defense of gays as a call to suicide bomb the mardi-gras... or something.

Anyway, what would be more useful than painstakingly going through all the ahadith and trying to twist every alleged deeds and actions of The Prophet as if there is an assumption that I must take it all as part of Islamic doctrine - it would be better to listen to the suggestion I made previously in great detail about treating the ahadith sceptically for the questionable historical sources that they are. And if any actions and deeds should be used for guidance, only use those that are consistent with Quranic philosophy.

And to clarify, when I said I expected there to be mistakes made by The Prophet, I didn't mean the "oops perhaps I shouldn't have slaughtered all those jews and gays for no reason" type. So when I hear ahadith about (for example) The Prophet torturing a jew for his gold - which is universally believed to be of questionable historical accuracy by Islamic scholars - then I dismiss it out of hand.

Quote:


Which is why I chose the 800 dead jew example.

Quote:


We are doing nothing of the sort. We are still stuck on the principle of how you handle the fact that Muhammed erred, but not in a way you know about.

Quote:


What type of mistakes do you expect Muhammed to have made?

Quote:


Aha, so that is what this thread is really about.

Watch this, G.

Old boy, do you rule out the use of porkies in your campaign against the Muselman? FD won’t say.

Soren wrote on Aug 11^th, 2015 at 7:05pm:


I didn’t ask that, old chap, as well you know.

You see, G? Cunning.

At least this one deflects. The other one evades.

Deflection, evasion, tendentious, mendacious. O brave new world with such wonderous things in’t,

Innit.

freediver wrote on Aug 11^th, 2015 at 6:22pm:


nope, thats just you desperately trying to twist this into something that it isn't.

- and of course avoid having to answer Karnal's questions in the process

the Islam-related higher-than-average death toll likely stems from the fact that Muslims have always been trying to emulate Mohammed's superpowers, whether they possessed them or not, to their own detriment. To make matters worse, while some of those powers were real, others were not more than old wives/husbands/same-sex life partners' tales.

You may have heard wondrous stories about how prepubescent girls touched by Mohammed instantly transformed into mature women by developing secondary sexual characteristics in a blink of an eye, how Mohammed once defeated Chuck Norris in single combat; or how Mohammed had his socks catapulted into a besieged fortress, causing the enemy to panic and beg for mercy. Some of that can't be true simply because Mohammed never wore socks, or because even he wasn't foolish enough to challenge Chuck Norris - otherwise Islam may have turned out to be a completely different religion.

It is a documented fact, however, that Mohammed would seriously impress his contemporaries with his ability to froth at the mouth while convulsing on the ground, see the same object no matter the direction he looked, have hallucinations of dazzling light, and commune with the divine (even though everyone knows Obama wasn't born yet). His amazing superpowers regarding prepubescent girls were also a documented fact.

The trouble with today's Islam is that Muslims still zealously insist on emulating the symptoms of Mohammed's paroxysms of epileptic insanity, psychopathology, obsessive-compulsive disorder, anxiety, paranoia, and other mental pathologies - a practice that is consistently turning generations of Muslim worshippers into a walking Medical Sales Desk Reference.

These and many more fun facts that are sure to give you hours of nightmares you'll discover in a meticulously researched book titled It's All About Muhammad. This profoundly insightful volume also explains why Submitters pray five times a day, why adoption is a no-no, why the Koran reads like a handy reference guide on how to properly kill and conquer Jews and other tax cheats, and much, much more. -

http://thepeoplescube.com/peoples-blog/secret-behind-mohammed-superpowers-video-t16309.html

Comes with vid.




Porky? Parody? Truth?