Ah. So it was replaced with an internal organisation that didn't replace it?

Can I get a straight answer now?

Thanks for the update Gandalf. A yes or no will suffice.

Should we expect anything different from whatever replacement organisation is put in place?

freediver wrote on Mar 17^th, 2016 at 10:34pm:


not if you are asking a muslim

freediver wrote on Mar 20^th, 2016 at 9:58am:


Yes, a school board is not an "organisation" - at least not like what you were attempting to frame it as - as a "replacement" for AFIC. And I am not refusing to answer - I already stated long back that there is no reason, nor any evidence from existing examples such as Canberra Taqwa school and Adelaide Islamic School - to suspect that locally run boards (local "organisations" if you really insist) would mismanage things like AFIC run schools.

No difference. That would be your reading comprehension again. Try reading the first sentence of my previous post to start with. That should help you.

The distinction I made between a big religious organisation (ie AFIC) externally running their institutions (such as schools) as businesses and locally owned and controlled school boards couldn't have been clearer.

You see, the reason you are having such difficulties here is that you can't (or refuse) to see any distinctions where muslims are involved. To you we're just a great big homogenous group of "muslims" - all sinister and all corrupt by default. Thats why you rhetorically ask me why the "replacement organisation" will be different. I say rhetorically, because thats exactly what it is - a rhetorical question. You are really stating something as fact - that any other "muslims" that take over are naturally going to be just as bad, since, well you know, we're muslims. So it then becomes a burden on me to disprove the natural order. Your line of inquiry can be summarised as 'muslims are naturally sinister and corrupt - so explain to me how this other group of muslims will be any different'. No doubt you will retort by saying it was me who came up with the idea that this behaviour is normal and inevitable. And of course by doing so you would once again get a Class A Fail for reading comprehension - since my point was about 'AFIC like organisations', big religious national, and often trans-national bodies being run like corporations who run their institutions for profit.

And naturally you see no difference between these bodies and local communities who take control of their school - for their community. We are all muslims - 'grinning muslims' as you so offensively put it some time ago, all with a hive mind and all conspiring together to be corrupt. AFIC will simply be replaced by AFIC  - local communities are by default as guilty as AFIC quite simply because - they are AFIC as far as you're concerned. Never mind trying to argue the proven track record of locally run schools - we are all AFIC. And thats why you ask the questions you ask - of course it makes no sense that replacing sinister muslims with sinister muslims would make any difference.

I thought you were boycotting this forum sprint.