Is there criminal liability for climate change denial?
...
However, many of these purveyors of misinformation are not merely exhibiting a genuine disbelief in the science of climate change. Rather, they intentionally deceive the public. The evidence of intent? There is no reasonable basis for the assertions they make. Additionally, many of these professional climate deniers are in positions that give them greater access to the facts and science of climate change. Exxon and Shell’s own scientists were among the first to sound the alarm about climate change, as detailed in Rich’s ‘Lost Decade’ article. Only later did Exxon begin its cover up, as detailed in the 2015 InsideClimate News series. Now, when professional deniers make assertions contrary to the conclusions of well over 95% of the scientific community, it’s not reasonable. Nor is it genuine.
The intentional deceit is not limited to the message. It also applies to the sources. In a misinformation feedback loop, certain media outlets owned and programmed by billionaire partisans regularly publish articles and op-eds from fossil fuel industry funded “think tanks.” These foundations operate essentially as public relations firms for fossil fuel and billionaires’ interests. They exhibit little tolerance for little intellectual independence. Yet they are intentionally disguised as independent “think tanks” in order to create the appearance of having a factual basis to dispute scientific studies and university scholarship. George Monbiot of the Guardian has written extensively on the topic.
This behavior and its consequences satisfies the fundamental elements of the type of conduct to which most societies attach criminal liability. For example criminal fraud is generally defined as intentional deceit in order to secure an unlawful gain or to cause a detrimental reliance. Here, the deceit is present, the knowledge of falsity is present, the securing of a financial advantage is present, and the detriment to life and property is present.
Some of these dishonest people post on this site